Where The Left Takes A Turn For The Worse

In a rather angry post I wrote this morning, I made the offhand comment that, in less weakkneed times, Michael Moore would be jailed for sedition.

Thanks to reader GB who took me to school on the Sedition Act. After refreshing myself on what it actually says, I realized I had "overspoken". I would of course never advocate jailing someone for being merely critical of the government. Thanks to GB for the clarification.

However, I do believe the government is within its rights to arrest and try those who aid the enemy in a time of war. Exhibit A, Ezra Pound.

For those who don't know, Pound was a respected American poet in the first half of the Twentieth Century who hated capitalism; he felt it created a culture inhospitable to poetry. He moved to Italy in 1925, and eventually went the way of the wackos:
In 1933 he met Mussolini, who praised his poetry. Pound became an active supporter of fascism, promoting it on radio broadcasts to England and the United States during World War II (1939-1945). In anticapitalist and anti-Semitic speeches, Pound denounced those he held responsible for the West's decline - in particular, Jewish bankers.

When the Allied troops occupied Italy in 1945 near the end of World War II, Pound was imprisoned for weeks in an open-air cage . . . In 1946 Pound was taken to Washington, D.C., to be tried for treason. His trial was canceled after he was declared legally insane, and he entered a hospital for the criminally insane where he continued to write and to receive visitors.
Pound's influential friends (T.S. Eliot, Robert Frost, Ernest Hemingway, and others) lobbied Washington for his release, and eventually got it in 1958.

Now, what is treason, exactly? The US Constitution, Section 3, Clause 1 states:
Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort.
While Michael Moore has certainly done some pro bono PR work for Saddam (and aided the propaganda ministries of some of our foes, such as Hezbollah, Castro, and France), he could never be convicted of treason (there have been fewer than 40 prosecutions in US history, something I just learned). But wouldn't a lot of us enjoy seeing Michael Moore get the Ezra Pound jitters in federal court for a few months?

I had planned on making some further comparisons between Pound and Moore, concerning their mutual phobia of capitalism* and their belief that war is a profiteering conspiracy. However, in doing the research, I soon tired of sifting through transcripts of Pound's vile broadcasts, and gave up.

Also, I would not want comparisons between the two men to lead anyone to infer any anti-Semitism on the part of Moore (at least not until I have evidence of it). Unlike him, I have scruples about drawing connections where none exist and impugning people's humanity just to make a political point. However, if you would like to infer from these comparisons that Moore is insane, be my guest.

And besides, we could never forget the one glaring difference between the two men: Pound had talent.

* Except when counting book royalties or box office receipts.

A Word From Colin Powell
Black Belt in Anti-Semitism
Strategy Questions
Woman Jailed For Smoking
Cambodiagate Memory Hole
Here We Go
Morning Memo
Report From Inside Najaf
Israelis Detain BBC Crew
New Blog Stamps

June 2004
July 2004
August 2004


* = recently updated

Blogroll This

News & Opinion
American Spectator
National Review
Weekly Standard
George Will
William F Buckley Jr
Charles Krauthammer
Christopher Hitchens
Political Wire

Declaration of Independence
US Constitution
Project Vote Smart
Electoral Vote Predictor
CIA World Factbook

W 04
Alabama Constitutional Reform
Forces International
Bill Monroe Stamp

The Left
The Spin Zone
Daily Kos
The Agonist
Eric Alterman
Talking Points Memo
Democratic Underground

Modern Times
A History of the American People
A History of the Twentieth Century
All The King's Men
Band of Angels
Absolom, Absolom!
Mere Christianity
Mystery Train

Mojo Magazine
Rock's Back Pages
Country Music Hall of Fame
Memphis Rock N Soul Museum
Sun Studio
Stax Museum of American Soul Music

Protest Warrior
Robert Penn Warren
Dreamland BBQ
Milo's Famous Tea

About Me
Mission Statement



Powered by Blogger

Subscribe with Bloglines

Weblog Commenting and Trackback by HaloScan.com

Content Copyright 2004